Did it really happen? |
For
it seems that back when Pope Francis was in the United States last week, Kim
Davis was one of a dozen people who were taken to the Vatican’s embassy in
Washington.
SHE
GOT A brief bit of face time, where Davis insists she was told by His Holiness
himself that he told her to “stay strong” in her ongoing fight against people who
expect her to fulfill her legal duties as clerk of Rowan County, Ky., by signing
off on all marriage licenses.
Even
those issued by gay couples wishing to have legal legitimacy added to their
personal relationships.
Most
of what has been spoken about this “meeting” has come from Davis. The woman who
isn’t even Catholic (she’s part of an Apostolic faith) wants us to think she
has the backing of one of the world’s leading religious faiths.
The
Vatican, which likes to think it is above all these worldly considerations,
initially came up with a “we can neither confirm nor deny” strategy in response
to Davis and her followers’ antics.
IT
LATER BECAME a “we confirm they met, but will not elaborate” type of response.
No longer the highlight of the papal visit |
“The
pope did not enter into the details of the situation of Mrs. Davis, and his
meeting with her should not be considered a form of support of her position in
all of its particular and complex aspects,” we were told. Then, we learned how the pope also greeted a gay couple and their friends during his tour -- the same amount of attention that Davis got.
Not
that I expect this to put the issue to rest – there are those who are going to
keep this issue alive for as long as possible. It may well be that it was
people within the Catholic church hierarchy who arranged for Davis to even be
on hand to see the Pope in Washington – perhaps those who want to push the
church toward the ideologue side with regards to the gay marriage debate.
JUST
BECAUSE THE courts may have ruled a certain way doesn’t mean there won’t be
those wishing to overturn them. Abortion was decided by the courts to be a
legitimate medical procedure more than four decades ago – yet the issue isn’t
anywhere near going away.
Now
I’m not about to claim Davis is flat-out lying when she talks about her papal
moment. Only that I realize being allowed into the pope’s presence shouldn’t be
thought of as being a bigger deal than it really is.
A comparable moment to Kim Davis? |
I
still remember in 1999 when Pope John Paul II came to St. Louis. One of the
people he met with was then-St. Louis Cardinals slugger Mark McGwire. They
shook hands, and McGwire got to introduce his son, Matt, to the pope.
The
whole incident lasted a few seconds before the pope moved on. Aside from
creating the opportunity for some jokes about the pope meeting with a cardinal,
it was just a brief tidbit.
YET
IN A papal journey to the Americas that ventured into Havana and saw Pope
Francis speak both at Madison Square Garden AND before Congress, there’s a very
good chance that this trip will have as its lingering memory the few seconds
that Davis worked her way to the front of the line and had papal face time.
Then again, the pope’s visit also got upstaged by the death of one-time New
York Yankees great Yogi Berra, so maybe the pope was going to struggle for
top-billing.
His death put Pope on Pg. 14 of NY Post |
By
that definition of papal attention, perhaps I should consider my own ’99 moment
– I was a United Press International reporter back then and I was in St. Louis
for the John Paul II trip. At one point, I was watching a motorcade through the
city and the pope was about 50 feet away from me when he looked in my direction
and waved.
For
his later mass at the now-former TWA Dome, I was relegated to another room and
had to watch him speak via a video screen connection. Admittedly, Davis’
proximity to a Pope was better than I had.
But
somehow, I think her experience was closer to mine than to a true papal
audience – which is the impression some conservative ideologues seem to want to
create. Which strikes me as a repulsive use of religion for one’s own beliefs!
-30-
No comments:
Post a Comment